US Pet Food: AI Shelf Visibility Insights for Brands

Interactive Dashboard

US Pet Food: AI Shelf Visibility Insights for Brands

A study of AI Recommendation Coverage (ARC) across ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini, measuring 241 pet food brands against 100 shopper prompts

Request Demo

Filter the report

Every chart below follows this selection.

AI Recommendation Coverage Leaderboard

AI pet food brand leaderboard

  • Three brands hold a quarter of the shelf. Purina Pro Plan at 199 recommendations, Hill’s Science Diet at 188 and Royal Canin at 158 — 8.6%, 8.1% and 6.8% of everything recommended, 23.5% between them.
  • Purina Pro Plan converts far better than the other two. 81 first-place answers against Hill’s 30 and Royal Canin’s 25, off a lead of only 11 recommendations.
  • Iams and Blue Buffalo are named often and chosen rarely. 143 and 131 recommendations for 6 and 4 first places between them.
  • This is a concentrated shelf. 241 distinct brands appear across 2,312 recommendations, and the fifteen on this chart take 1,327 of them — 57%.

*All interactive charts are best viewed on desktop or tablet.

Which brands hold up across all AI surfaces?

AI pet food brand consistency by assistant

  • Purina Pro Plan and Hill’s Science Diet hold across all three assistants. Pro Plan sits at 10.7%, 7.3% and 8.0%, Hill’s at 9.4%, 7.3% and 7.8% — the only two brands above 7% on every assistant.
  • Purina ONE is a ChatGPT brand. 7.5% there against 2.9% on Gemini, a 2.6x gap — the widest of any top-seven brand.
  • Iams shows the same tilt. 9.4% on ChatGPT, 5.1% on Claude and 4.2% on Gemini, so Gemini gives it less than half the share ChatGPT does.
  • Blue Buffalo runs the other way. 4.0% on ChatGPT against 6.6% on Gemini — the only top-five brand whose weakest surface is ChatGPT.
  • Orijen and Open Farm are all but missing from ChatGPT. 0.3% and 0.4% there, against up to 3.1% and 2.8% on the other two.

*Each cell is the brand's share of that assistant's total recommendations. Only the top 15 brands are shown, so a column sums to roughly a third rather than 100%.

Recommendations, redrawn by parent company

AI pet food recommendations by parent company

  • Two owners hold 43% of the shelf. Mars Petcare at 505 recommendations and Nestlé at 500 — 21.8% and 21.6% — are level, and nobody else clears 10%.
  • Each reaches the top through a few brands. Nestlé’s total is led by Purina Pro Plan and Purina ONE, 305 of its 500; Mars gets there with Royal Canin and Iams, two of the four most-recommended brands on the page.
  • Colgate-Palmolive is a distant third. Hill’s takes it to 218 recommendations, 9.4% — less than half of either leader.
  • General Mills is here on one brand. Its 177 recommendations are mostly Blue Buffalo, 137 of them. After that comes a long tail: 116 manufacturers appear, and the six largest hold 78% of the attributed recommendations.

*Covers the 2,078 of 2,312 recommendations that name a manufacturer. The other 234 have none recorded and are excluded from this view.

Sources the assistants get their evidence from

  • One retailer is the evidence base. chewy.com accounts for 711 of the 2,148 citations counted — eight times walmart.com, the next retailer on the list.
  • ChatGPT leans on it hardest. 519 of its citations are chewy.com, against 184 for Claude and 8 for Gemini.
  • Gemini cites nothing you can act on. 605 of its citations route through grounding redirects, so its sourcing cannot be audited or influenced through the usual channels.
  • Specialist advice sites matter more here than general media. dogfoodadvisor.com (27) and petmd.com (23) are cited almost entirely by Claude.

*Counts are citations rather than product recommendations. All interactive charts are best viewed on desktop or tablet.

What this means for your brand

This report is built from 100 real shopping prompts run across ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini. Every brand each assistant recommended was captured using DataWeave’s platform, along with the position it held in the answer and the sources cited. Recommendations are rank-weighted so first place counts for more than eighth, and brands are normalized and grouped under the manufacturer recorded for each product.

Run against your own portfolio, the same method answers three questions most brands cannot currently answer: where you rank in AI answers and against whom, which assistants you are losing on, and whether the fix sits in your retailer product pages or in third-party editorial.

This report analyzes the Pet Food category. DataWeave measures the same thing across any category and market, continuously rather than as a snapshot. Talk to us to find out where your brands stand on the AI shelf.

Get in touch