Less is More in Holiday Pricing: The Case for a Simple, Stable Approach This Holiday Season

With pricing making headlines more frequently than ever, now is the perfect moment for retailers to take a step back and rethink their holiday strategy. The heightened focus on pricing—driven by economic uncertainties, inflationary pressures, and fluctuating supply chain dynamics—presents a unique opportunity for retailers to not only meet customer expectations but to exceed them by rebuilding trust. In today’s climate, where consumer confidence is often fragile, the perception of fair pricing can be a significant differentiator. This is especially true during the holiday season when shoppers are more budget-conscious, and every dollar counts.

Rather than focusing on the price of individual items, consumers are increasingly concerned with the total amount they spend at checkout. This means the overall basket cost, rather than the price tag on a single product, holds greater sway in determining whether a customer feels they’ve gotten a good deal. Retailers who can maintain steady, predictable basket pricing—despite external pressures such as supply chain disruptions or increased competition—will stand out as reliable and customer-centric.

Pricing Strategy for the Holiday Season

Your pricing strategy sets the tone for fostering and maintaining customer trust during the busy holiday season. From establishing initial prices to managing markdowns, having a stable, well-thought-out plan is crucial to balancing profitability with customer satisfaction. Below are several guiding principles to help you navigate this critical time frame:

Anchor Your Prices Early on Key Holiday Items

Identify the products that are likely to drive traffic and sales during the holiday period and set your prices strategically early on. Use these prices as a ceiling that you won’t exceed, allowing customers to trust that they’re getting consistent value. By establishing this anchor price, you create a sense of stability in an otherwise fluctuating market, helping your customers feel confident that they won’t face price hikes on essential holiday items.

Prepare for Competitive Moves

The holiday season is notorious for aggressive pricing tactics by competitors, so you’ll need to remain agile. Be prepared to make strategic price reductions when necessary, but ensure you stay below your anchored price to avoid eroding trust. Monitoring competitors closely and adjusting your strategy without undermining your overall value proposition will be key to maintaining a competitive edge.

To accomplish this, having reliable and timely competitor pricing data is essential. A sophisticated pricing intelligence platform like DataWeave’s can get the job done, which is equipped to handle the scale and speed demanded during the fast-paced holiday season.

Collaborate with Vendors on Promotions

Strong vendor relationships are crucial during the holiday season. By working closely with your suppliers, you can develop compelling promotions that not only attract customers but also ensure you have adequate inventory levels to support any reduced pricing strategies. Vendors may offer additional incentives or discounts during this period, and leveraging those to provide deeper savings can help retailers pass along better deals to customers without sacrificing margin.

Pre-Holiday Markdowns

Pre-holiday markdowns are an essential tool to clear out older inventory and make room for newer, more seasonal items. Get ahead of these markdowns by tracking trends and data from previous years. This will allow you to anticipate demand and address any overstocking issues early, ensuring that your shelves are stocked with the right products at the right time.

Post-Holiday Markdowns

Once the holiday rush subsides, differentiating between products is crucial. For “In and Out” items, which are seasonal or limited-time offers, your goal should be to clear through inventory as quickly as possible to free up valuable shelf space for upcoming product cycles. For products that are part of your regular planogram, the focus should shift to adjusting inventory levels back down to non-holiday norms, ensuring you’re not left with excess stock that could tie up cash flow in the slower months ahead.

Manage Markdowns at the Store/Item Level

Not all stores or products will move at the same pace, so it’s essential to manage markdowns on a granular level. Each store has different inventory turnover rates, and customer demand may vary from one location to another. Tailoring markdown strategies to the specific needs of individual stores and products allows for greater flexibility and ensures you’re maximizing sell-through while minimizing excess stock.

Managing the Rest of the Assortment

While holiday-specific items will undoubtedly capture much of the attention from customers due to the increased volume and seasonal demand, it’s essential to remember that the rest of the customer’s basket—comprised of non-holiday items—plays a pivotal role in their overall shopping experience. Retailers often focus heavily on optimizing prices for holiday items, but maintaining a consistent and customer-friendly pricing strategy across the entire assortment is equally important. Neglecting non-holiday items can erode trust and diminish the effectiveness of the overall holiday pricing strategy. Customers shop holistically, and their perception of your brand is shaped by the totality of their shopping experience, not just individual product categories.

While holiday promotions may attract traffic, it’s the consistency and transparency of your broader pricing strategy that will strengthen trust and encourage repeat business. After all, the holiday season is not just about winning a single transaction—it’s about building relationships that extend well into the new year.

A few critical factors to consider for your non-holiday assortment:

Minimize Price Increases Unless Absolutely Necessary

The holiday season is a delicate time when customers are highly sensitive to pricing. Sudden, unexpected price hikes, especially on everyday, non-seasonal items, can quickly erode the trust you’ve worked hard to build. Customers may forgive small fluctuations, but if they perceive a retailer is taking advantage of holiday demand or inflationary pressures to unnecessarily raise prices, that goodwill can evaporate. By maintaining steady pricing, you reinforce the idea that your brand prioritizes fairness over opportunism, especially in a period marked by heightened scrutiny around pricing practices.

Evaluate Price Gaps Between Product Tiers

A key element of pricing strategy that retailers should focus on is maintaining appropriate price gaps between product tiers, such as private label and national brands. Ensuring that the price difference between these tiers remains clear and consistent helps reinforce a value proposition for both types of customers: those who seek premium national brands and those who are value-oriented and gravitate toward private label options. If the price gap becomes too narrow, customers may be confused about the differentiation between products, leading to dissatisfaction or lost sales.

Ensure Accurate Value Sizing

One of the most effective ways to gain customer trust is through clear, transparent pricing, particularly when it comes to value sizing. Misleading unit pricing, whether intentional or accidental, can quickly frustrate customers, making them feel that they are being deceived. Ensure that unit pricing is visible, logical, and consistent across all product categories, allowing customers to make informed choices without feeling overwhelmed or misled. By offering transparency in this area, you can foster a sense of fairness and accountability, further building your reputation as a customer-first retailer.

Maintain Price Links Across Your Assortments

Consistency in pricing across various categories and product lines is crucial to managing customer expectations. Pricing disparities between similar products or across different stores in your chain can create confusion and frustration, leading to negative perceptions of your brand. Customers expect a seamless shopping experience, and this includes consistency in pricing, no matter what they buy or where they buy it. Establishing and maintaining price links within your assortment will ensure that your broader pricing strategy remains aligned with customer expectations, reinforcing reliability.

Trust is Your Greatest Currency

In a retail environment where customers are constantly bombarded with news about inflation, price hikes, and economic instability, trust is your greatest asset. Negative perceptions surrounding pricing, whether it’s from the media or personal experiences, can make customers wary and hesitant. By committing to a stable, transparent, and fair pricing strategy—not just for holiday items but across the entire assortment—you can differentiate yourself in the market and foster long-term loyalty. Stability and consistency in your pricing model allow customers to feel confident that they’re getting good value every time they shop with you, regardless of external economic pressures.

It’s important to prioritize the customer relationship above all else, even if that means sacrificing some immediate short-term gains. Retailers who opt for quick wins through aggressive price changes may see a temporary boost in profits but risk damaging long-term customer loyalty. On the other hand, by focusing on providing a consistent and fair experience, you position your brand as a reliable choice, one that customers will return to not just during the holidays but throughout the entire year.

In a season where every retailer is vying for the same holiday dollar, your approach to pricing must stand out by emphasizing trust, loyalty, and customer satisfaction. Pricing transparency and fairness are key differentiators, especially in an environment where many retailers will be tempted to capitalize on increased demand by raising prices or reducing promotions. Instead, leading with trust and focusing on stability will allow you to rise above the noise and deliver a superior customer experience.

In Summary: Stability Wins

This holiday season, the winning strategy isn’t about pushing for the highest possible margins or taking advantage of seasonal demand spikes. It’s about the bigger picture—building lasting customer relationships that extend well beyond the holidays. By prioritizing consistency in your pricing, maintaining transparency across your assortment, and leading with trust, you’ll not only achieve success during the holiday period but also set the stage for long-term customer loyalty.

In short, stability wins. Prioritize the customer experience, remain consistent in your approach, and lead with trust. Doing so will ensure that your customers not only choose you during the holidays but continue to choose you long into the future.

To learn more, reach out and chat with us today!

- Eddy Salas
SVP Retail Strategy DataWeave, 12th Sep, 2024

E Commerce Intelligent Pricing pricing analytics Pricing insights Pricing Strategies US